top of page

CrossFit's Untold Story: Controversial Aspects That Could Change Your View Forever!


Hey there, CrossFit enthusiasts and skeptics alike! I'm Trista, and I've been living and breathing CrossFit for over 12 years. As an affiliate gym owner & a certified CrossFit Level 3 trainer, I've seen it all – the good, the bad, and yes, the controversial. Today, let's have a candid chat about some of those controversial aspects of CrossFit. It's time to shed some light on the darker corners and see what's really going on.

Controversy 1: Injury Risks

 Understanding the Risk

CrossFit, like any sport, comes with its share of injury risks. I remember when I first started, the thrill of pushing my limits was addictive. However as my coaching evolved & my knowledge of the methodology grew, I realized the importance of mastering technique before introducing heavier weights and higher intensity. 

 Mitigating the Risks

It's all about how you approach the workout. I always tell my newbies, "Technique before intensity!" We focus heavily on proper form, gradually increasing weight &  intensity, and listening to our bodies. Remember, an experienced  coach and a sensible approach are your best defenses against injury.

Controversy 2: Criticism of Competitive Culture

 The Competitive Edge

CrossFit's competitive streak can be a double-edged sword. On one hand, it drives us to be our best. On the other, it can push some to take unnecessary risks. I remind members that we aren’t here to compete everyday. Some days, we are just here to train. Competing every single day leads to burn out. Athletes should listen to their body and push hard on the days they are feeling great and pull back on the days they have a little less to give. 

 Balancing Competition and Community

The key? Balance. Competition should lift you, not break you. In our gym, we celebrate personal victories and group successes equally. It's not just about winning; it's about growing stronger together. The last to finish often gets the most cheers. In our affiliate we celebrate the firsts (pull ups, box jumps, RX workout) & we celebrate the out of gym victories (new job, new house, baby on the way!) 

Controversy 3: Claims of Cult-like Atmosphere

 Community vs. Cult

"Cult-like" is a term I've heard thrown around about CrossFit. Sure, we're passionate, dedicated, and maybe a bit obsessive about our WODs (Workout of the Day). But at its heart, CrossFit is about community. It's a place where you'll find support, encouragement, and a sense of belonging. That's not a cult; that's family. Many of the athletes in our affiliate live away from their families or they’re looking for active friends. Green Fire CrossFit is a 2nd home for our athletes and even their families. What makes me the most proud about our affiliate is that our athletes describe it as OUR gym. What WE do at Green Fire. Good humans, supporting, growing and evolving together in a place that helps them flourish. 

Controversy 4: Questionable Nutrition and Health Advice

 Nutrition in Focus

Nutrition is another hot topic in CrossFit circles. Paleo, Keto, Zone – you name it, someone in CrossFit is probably trying it. But remember, nutrition is deeply personal. What works for one may not work for another. As a nutrition coach, I offer services to help you find what works for you. 

 Making Informed Choices

I always encourage my members to do their research, consult health professionals, and listen to their bodies. It's not about following the crowd; it's about finding what fuels your body best. I also teach our athletes to focus on what their bodies can do, not just what they look like. 

Controversy 5: Overemphasis on Intensity and Volume

 The Intensity Debate

CrossFit's high intensity can be intimidating. We introduce intensity only when our athletes are equipped with proper form and good mechanics. It's also crucial to understand that intensity is relative to each individual. 

 Finding the Right Balance

Your max effort is unique to you. It's not about keeping up with the person next to you; it's about your own progress. We focus on scaling workouts to fit each individual's ability, ensuring a challenging yet safe workout.


Addressing these controversial aspects of CrossFit isn't about dismissing them; it's about understanding and navigating them with care. At the end of the day, CrossFit is more than just a workout regime; it's a lifestyle that emphasizes strength, health, and community.

What Next?

Got more questions or thoughts about CrossFit? Want to experience how we do things differently? Drop by my gym or hit us up online. Let's keep this conversation going and continue to grow stronger, together.



  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • TikTok
bottom of page